Dear Diana,
Yes, I know I've already posted some complaints about the things you've written. However, given that I've done some growing up since then, I have some more.
You style yourself as size-positive, but here's the thing: having a few characters of size isn't the same as truly giving fat people positive fictional role models - not if they're written the way you portray them. And as a woman of some size who's in a relationship with a beautiful, intelligent, thoughtful woman of considerable size, I have a problem with them.
Wednesday, October 9, 2013
Monday, December 26, 2011
"The Descendants": More of the Same
If I find out about one more movie or book where the plot involves the main character losing his or her shit against a pretty background of voiceless natives, I am going to lose mine.
Monday, July 11, 2011
Two rants: my dad and Casey Anthony
A married couple, friends of my parents', are staying with my family at the moment, and they haven't seen me in quite a while. As such, they're interested in what I've been doing at school. Tonight at dinner, my mom's friend K* asked me what my favorite class was at school this past year. I replied that I had really enjoyed my anthropology class and my history class - Race as the History of an Idea.
To which my father replied, "Race isn't an idea. It's a skin color."
Oy.
To which my father replied, "Race isn't an idea. It's a skin color."
Oy.
Friday, June 3, 2011
Deconstructing Beth: The Genetics of the Fabray-Puckerman Cross
This might be a small thing, but it seems to me that a lot of Glee fic-writers are trying to further whitewash a white person. Namely: Drizzle, aka Jackie Daniels, aka Beth Corcoran-by-adoption.
Two words for those writers: dominant genes.
Given the little we've seen of Puck's family (his mother and sister), it is highly unlikely that Quinn and Puck's daughter is going to be blonde. The show never tells us anything about his father, so for all intents and purposes he could have had a blond allele somewhere in his gene pool, but how likely is it that his mother would have married anyone who didn't "look Jewish?" Remember, this is a woman who compared her son to the Nazis for not dating a Jewish girl.
Beth could have light eyes; her mother is probably hazel/hazel or hazel/blue (the elder Fabrays look very stereotypically Anglo), and her father has hazel-green eyes. But her father is olive-skinned and skin color is a polygenic trait, so at the very least, the child is probably not going to be ghost-pale like Quinn.
She probably also won't be a physical copy of Quinn. You don't need to know all about genetic recombination to know that the chances of inheriting every single one of one parent's traits are infinitesimally small. Now that the show has told us that Quinn may or may not be naturally thin (we're never told if her past obesity was a result of genetics, stress eating, or some other factor), this brings Beth's future body type into question, too. In fact, even without his constant workouts, Puck is fairly stocky and heavy-jawed; Beth could easily be so as well.
In short: I wish that Glee writers would take a more open-minded approach to writing about a grown-up Baby Fabray. There are enough lily-white princesses on the show as it is; there needn't be another one.
Two words for those writers: dominant genes.
Given the little we've seen of Puck's family (his mother and sister), it is highly unlikely that Quinn and Puck's daughter is going to be blonde. The show never tells us anything about his father, so for all intents and purposes he could have had a blond allele somewhere in his gene pool, but how likely is it that his mother would have married anyone who didn't "look Jewish?" Remember, this is a woman who compared her son to the Nazis for not dating a Jewish girl.
Beth could have light eyes; her mother is probably hazel/hazel or hazel/blue (the elder Fabrays look very stereotypically Anglo), and her father has hazel-green eyes. But her father is olive-skinned and skin color is a polygenic trait, so at the very least, the child is probably not going to be ghost-pale like Quinn.
She probably also won't be a physical copy of Quinn. You don't need to know all about genetic recombination to know that the chances of inheriting every single one of one parent's traits are infinitesimally small. Now that the show has told us that Quinn may or may not be naturally thin (we're never told if her past obesity was a result of genetics, stress eating, or some other factor), this brings Beth's future body type into question, too. In fact, even without his constant workouts, Puck is fairly stocky and heavy-jawed; Beth could easily be so as well.
In short: I wish that Glee writers would take a more open-minded approach to writing about a grown-up Baby Fabray. There are enough lily-white princesses on the show as it is; there needn't be another one.
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Diana Gabaldon and the Chamber of Racism
For those of you who haven't read any of Diana Gabaldon's work, here's a (comparatively light) summary of the racism, sexism, and homophobia she exhibits in her work. The seventh book is exempted from this because I haven't read it much.
The premise is all right - Claire Randall, a former field nurse in World War II, is on vacation with her husband Frank Randall in the Scottish Highlands. He wants to talk to a local reverend about a famous ancestor of his, Jonathan "Black Jack" Randall, who coincides nicely with Frank's history mania and was in Scotland at the time of the 1745 Rising.
It gets even more "interesting" when Claire steps through a stone circle and ends up two hundred years back in time. (The stone circle is utilized, backwards and forwards, multiple times.)
The premise is all right - Claire Randall, a former field nurse in World War II, is on vacation with her husband Frank Randall in the Scottish Highlands. He wants to talk to a local reverend about a famous ancestor of his, Jonathan "Black Jack" Randall, who coincides nicely with Frank's history mania and was in Scotland at the time of the 1745 Rising.
It gets even more "interesting" when Claire steps through a stone circle and ends up two hundred years back in time. (The stone circle is utilized, backwards and forwards, multiple times.)
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
The Obligatory Introduction Post
Hi, everyone, and welcome to Word of Nerd.
My profile pretty much explains the bare bones of who I am, but here's a little more, if you're interested. Call me Doodling. I'm fairly new to the blog scene, but I'm curious about just about everything, including but not limited to literature, Star Trek, trivia, anthropology, and the world. I grew up in a small town with fairly narrow horizons, and am doing my best to broaden them now, so please bear with me.
Some of my posts may be cross-posted from my Livejournal account, to which I won't link because it's mainly a fic journal (I'm sure you all want to be neither traumatized nor bored).
I'm glad to have you here.
My profile pretty much explains the bare bones of who I am, but here's a little more, if you're interested. Call me Doodling. I'm fairly new to the blog scene, but I'm curious about just about everything, including but not limited to literature, Star Trek, trivia, anthropology, and the world. I grew up in a small town with fairly narrow horizons, and am doing my best to broaden them now, so please bear with me.
Some of my posts may be cross-posted from my Livejournal account, to which I won't link because it's mainly a fic journal (I'm sure you all want to be neither traumatized nor bored).
I'm glad to have you here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)